News

Published: 9 July 2026

Last updated: 23 October 2026

Directors’ loan accounts are common in owner-managed companies and can provide a legitimate way of recording money passing between a director and the company. However, any withdrawals must be properly authorised, accurately recorded and dealt with in accordance with the Companies Act 2006 and the company’s constitution.

The High Court decision in McCarthy v Marshall [2026] EWHC 1585 (Ch) provides an important example of the potential consequences of getting this wrong. The Court found that a director’s use of a director’s loan account to fund personal expenditure amounted to a fraudulent breach of his duties to the company, even though the director intended to repay the money.

What is a director’s loan account?

A director’s loan account records money passing between a director and the company, other than ordinary salary, expenses, dividends or other payments properly due to the director.

The account may be either in credit or overdrawn, depending on who owes whom. If the account is in credit, the company owes money to the director. If it is overdrawn, the director owes money to the company.

While directors’ loan accounts are commonly used, they must be operated carefully, with clear records showing the payments made and the authority for them.

What happened in McCarthy v Marshall?

The case concerned two directors and shareholders of a group of companies. One of the directors, who was responsible for the day-to-day running of the business, had used company funds over a number of years to pay personal expenses through a director’s loan account.

He argued that this arrangement had been agreed with his fellow director. However, the Court rejected that argument and accepted evidence that the other director neither knew about nor authorised the withdrawals.

Why was the director liable?

All company directors owe duties of loyalty and trust to the company, known as their fiduciary duties. Directors are also subject to duties under the Companies Act 2006.

In this case, the Court found that the loan account had been operated without proper authority and that the misuse of company money for personal purposes constituted a fraudulent breach of the director’s fiduciary duties.

Importantly, the Court emphasised that the fact the director intended to repay the money did not excuse the conduct. The company received no benefit from the arrangement and was exposed to potential financial harm, including reduced cash flow and increased borrowing requirements.

The case demonstrates that an intention to repay does not, by itself, make an unauthorised withdrawal acceptable.

Does a director’s loan require shareholder approval?

The Companies Act 2006 contains rules governing loans and similar transactions involving company directors. Under section 197, member approval may be required before a company makes a loan to one of its directors.

However, not every loan to a director will automatically require shareholder approval. The statutory regime contains relevant exceptions, so the particular circumstances of the proposed loan or withdrawal must be considered carefully.

The company’s articles of association and any shareholders’ agreement should also be checked. These documents may contain additional requirements governing a director’s authority to withdraw or borrow money from the company.

Where approval is required, it should be obtained before the money is paid to the director.

What happens if a director’s loan is not authorised?

Where money has been withdrawn without the necessary authority, the director may be required to repay the money or restore it to the company. They may also face a claim for breach of their duties as a director, potentially resulting in serious personal consequences.

As demonstrated by McCarthy v Marshall, an intention to repay the money will not necessarily excuse an unauthorised withdrawal. Informal practices or understandings between directors may also be difficult to establish if appropriate approval and records are not in place.

However, not every unauthorised loan will necessarily amount to fraud or dishonesty. The consequences will depend on the circumstances, including what was authorised, what the director understood and how the loan account was operated.

Practical safeguards for directors and companies

Many owner-managed businesses operate informal arrangements between directors and the company. Directors may occasionally withdraw funds on the understanding that the amounts will be repaid later through dividends, salary adjustments or loan account credits.

However, informal practice is not a substitute for proper corporate authority. Directors and companies should ensure that:

  • directors understand and remain mindful of their duties to the company;
  • any loan, payment or withdrawal is properly documented;
  • the company’s articles of association, any shareholders’ agreement and the relevant statutory requirements are checked;
  • appropriate board consideration takes place and the company keeps a clear record of any decisions made;
  • any necessary member approval is obtained before funds are paid to a director; and
  • directors’ loan accounts are accurately maintained and regularly reviewed.

Having clear approvals and records in place can help protect both the company and its directors if questions are later raised about a particular payment or withdrawal.

When should a company or director seek legal advice?

Taking advice at an early stage can help directors and companies understand their responsibilities and reduce the risk of a future dispute.

Legal advice should be considered where:

  • a significant payment or withdrawal is proposed;
  • there is uncertainty about whether the director has authority to withdraw the money;
  • it is unclear whether board or member approval is required;
  • a director’s loan account has become materially overdrawn;
  • directors or shareholders disagree about what was authorised; or
  • the company wants to recover money from a director.

Advice may also be appropriate when reviewing historic transactions or putting more formal arrangements in place for the future.

Key points for directors and companies

The decision in McCarthy v Marshall reinforces a long-established principle: company money belongs to the company, not its directors.

Even where there is no intention to cause a loss and repayment is anticipated, directors who treat company funds as a personal source of finance without proper authority may face repayment or restoration obligations and claims for breach of their duties.

Companies should regularly review the operation of their directors’ loan accounts and ensure appropriate authority, approvals and records are in place. Informal practice is not a substitute for proper authority.

Taking advice early can help avoid disputes and reduce the risk of costly litigation. If you would like to speak to our corporate team, please contact Katherine Gilmour or Brian Levine in our Corporate and Business Team.

If money is owed to the company, our Business Asset and Debt Recovery team can provide clear, practical advice on the options available to recover it.

Call our team on 0800 652 8373 or email [email protected].